But What Can You Do? tracks where 2026 candidates stand on U.S. weapons and funding for the government of Israel. How we check

Seth Magaziner

Democrat · U.S. House, Rhode Island District 2
?Supported sending weapons or funding in 2 of 5 tracked votes

Magaziner cosponsored a September 2025 bill to stop transfers of certain offensive weapons to the government of Israel, and said he would support no more until conditions he set on Gaza and the West Bank are met. In July 2026 he voted to cut that government's military aid.

✉  Copy a message to send them

We don’t have a campaign email on file yet. Copy this message and send it through their website or a public social account.

If you send this from your own email, cc replies@butwhatcanyoudo.org so we can post their answer.

✆  Call DC office

Deep Dive

Seth Magaziner has represented Rhode Island's 2nd District since January 2023, and was the state's general treasurer from 2015 to 2023. He sits on the Homeland Security Committee, where he is the ranking member of its subcommittee on counterterrorism and intelligence. He was unopposed in the Democratic primary on September 9, 2026, and faces Victor Mellor, the Republican nominee, on November 3, 2026.

The fullest thing he has said on this question is the statement he issued on September 5, 2025. In it he writes that he had cosponsored a bill to stop the transfer of certain offensive weaponry from the United States to the government of Israel, and that he did it to pressure Prime Minister Netanyahu to implement a ceasefire in Gaza, to allow significantly increased humanitarian aid into Gaza, and to stop the expansion of settlements in the West Bank. The withholding he describes is conditional and he names the conditions: he says he will not support providing the Netanyahu government with additional offensive weaponry until food and medicine are surged into Gaza, until the prime minister presents a workable proposal to end the war, until independent journalists are permitted to report from Gaza, and until the rule of law is enforced impartially in the West Bank. He also writes in the same statement that the government of Israel has withheld food and medicine from the civilian population in Gaza, causing mass suffering. The bill is H.R. 3565, sponsored by Rep. Delia Ramirez of Illinois; the House recorded his cosponsorship on September 8, 2025. Defensive systems are a separate matter for him, and what he says about them is on his research page.

He puts his own earlier support in the same frame rather than leaving it out. He writes that in April of 2024 he joined 85% of his colleagues in Congress in voting to provide military assistance to Israel, and that the situation changed over the following year and a half. In July 2026 he was one of 103 House Democrats who voted for an amendment to cut American military aid to the government of Israel, and said afterward on social media that "U.S. security assistance can no longer serve as a blank check for actions that make Israelis, Palestinians, and the region as a whole less safe."

On aid to Palestinians he has said the same thing for longer. In February 2024 he and Rep. Gabe Amo issued a joint statement saying they could not support a standalone Israel funding bill in its current form, because it carried no humanitarian aid for civilians in Gaza and no support for Ukraine or the Indo-Pacific, and writing that humanitarian aid to Gaza is vital to the long-term security of Israelis and Palestinians. When the first phase of a ceasefire was announced in October 2025 he called it welcome and joyful news and said aid needs to drastically increase and flow unimpeded into Gaza. In June 2026 he was one of 42 lawmakers who asked the State Department to publish what the government of Israel spends on West Bank settlements and to deduct that amount from the loan guarantees the United States makes available to it, which a twenty-year-old law requires. That letter is a group text and is described here as one.

He describes the war in both directions and in one document. He calls Hamas a bloodthirsty terrorist organization that continues to hold innocent hostages and says the government of Israel has a right to defend itself against attacks like those of October 7, 2023, and in the same statement he writes that injustice does not justify injustice, and the prolonged suffering of civilians in Gaza must end. In June 2024 he said of Prime Minister Netanyahu that he had been "bad for Israel, bad for Palestinians, bad for America", while saying he would attend the prime minister's address to Congress because he thought it his job to hear a visiting head of state.

The American Israel Public Affairs Committee, a lobbying organization that works to strengthen the relationship between the United States and the government of Israel and which also runs political committees that give to candidates, had endorsed him. In the days after the July 2026 vote it took the donation links off his profile on its fundraising portal, along with those of fourteen other Democrats it had endorsed. His campaign site has no issues page and nothing on it touches this subject. What he has said about antisemitism, the letters he has signed with other Jewish members of Congress, and everything else found for this card are on his research page.

The record

Supported sending weapons or funding in 2 of 5 tracked votes · Cosponsors the Block the Bombs Act

Floor votes
H.R. 6126 - Israel Security Supplemental Appropriations Act2023-11-02 · Passed 226-196
✓ Voted No
voted against sending it
H.R. 7217 - Israel Security Supplemental Appropriations Act, 20242024-02-06 · Failed 250-180 (needed 2/3 under suspension)
✓ Voted No
voted against sending it
H.R. 8034 - Israel Security Supplemental Appropriations Act, 20242024-04-20 · Passed 366-58
✗ Voted Yes
supported sending it
H.R. 8369 - Israel Security Assistance Support Act2024-05-16 · Passed 224-187
– Did not vote
H.R. 8595 - Massie amendment (Part A No. 8) to bar FY27 funds for Israel and cut $3.3B in Foreign Military Financing2026-07-15 · Failed 104-314
✓ Voted Yes
voted to limit or block it
H.Amdt. 55 to H.R. 4016 - strike $500M for Israeli Cooperative Programs2025-07-18 · Failed 6-422 (only 6 voted to cut)
✗ Voted No
voted against limiting it
Bill sponsorship
H.R. 3565 - Block the Bombs ActWould bar transfer of 2,000-lb/BLU-109 bunker busters, JDAMs, 120mm tank rounds, and 155mm artillery shells to Israel. Does not affect Iron
Co-sponsorbacks this bill to restrict weapons transfers
H.R. 1229 - United States-Israel Defense Partnership Act of 2025Formalizes/expands bilateral defense cooperation with Israel.
Not sponsoringhas not backed this support bill
How this mark works

We track key votes on sending U.S. weapons and money to the government of Israel. A check means every tracked vote they cast came down against sending more, on the side of peace and de-escalation. A question mark means a mixed record: they sided with sending up to half of the time. An X means they voted to send more weapons and money in over half of their tracked votes, even as the way those weapons and dollars were being used became more and more obvious. At exactly half, money this election cycle from a lobbying group we track, or an endorsement from a group that backs sending weapons, makes it an X. Only votes actually cast are counted. Where a candidate has no recorded votes on these bills, the mark comes instead from a reviewed reading of their public record (money from the lobbying groups we track, endorsements, and their own words since January 26, 2024). There an X also covers fully backing the conduct of the war by the government of Israel without significant reservations, and a question mark also covers speaking about Israel without saying clearly where they stand on U.S. weapons and funding. A dash means No Position Found: we found nothing in their own words about Israel, Gaza or the war.

See a dash? Ask the candidate where they stand, then send us their answer and we'll review it and update the mark. Or volunteer to help review candidates.

Voted to send weapons or funding in some, but no more than half, of their recorded tracked votes. (Supported sending weapons or funding in 2 of 5 tracked votes.)

The money

$19K in lifetime support from the five lobbying groups we track

Lifetime support from the five lobbying groups we track
AIPAC PAC: $15,000 · DMFI: $4,300
Support-only OpenFEC data (as of 2026-10-03). Opposition independent expenditures are excluded.
Who these lobbying groups are
AIPAC$15,000The American Israel Public Affairs Committee; its PAC backs candidates it sees as strengthening U.S. ties with the government of Israel, including continued U.S. military aid.DMFI PAC$4,300Democratic Majority for Israel's PAC; calls itself the home for pro-Israel Democrats and backs Democratic candidates who support a strong U.S. alliance with the government of Israel.Direct contributions and independent expenditures supporting this candidate from the five lobbying groups we track, every cycle each has filed, through 2026. Excludes earmarked and conduit contributions.

In their words

“Today, after much reflection, I cosponsored H.R. 3565, a bill to stop the transfer of certain offensive weaponry from the United States to Israel. I have taken this action to do my part to pressure Prime Minister Netanyahu to implement a ceasefire in Gaza, allow significantly increased humanitarian aid into Gaza, and to stop the expansion of settlements in the West Bank.”
Source ↗, 2025-09-05
“I will continue to support defensive systems like Iron Dome that protect civilians, as well as targeted actions to remove what remains of Hamas, but I will not support providing the Netanyahu government with additional offensive weaponry until food and medicine are surged into Gaza, Netanyahu presents a workable proposal to end the war that ensures the safety and dignity for both Israelis and Palestinians, independent journalists are permitted to report from Gaza, and rule of law is enforced impartially in the West Bank.”
Source ↗, 2025-09-05
“In April of 2024, I joined 85% of my colleagues in Congress in voting to provide military assistance to Israel. I did so, mindful of the deadly threat that Hamas, Iran, Hezbollah, and other bad actors posed to the civilian population in Israel and across the region.”
Source ↗, 2025-09-05
“The acts of terror committed by Hamas are horrific. But injustice does not justify injustice, and the prolonged suffering of civilians in Gaza must end.”
Source ↗, 2025-09-05
“Humanitarian aid to Gaza is vital to the long-term security of Israelis and Palestinians. Support for Ukraine and the Indo-Pacific is essential to our cause of democracy around the world. These priorities must be included in a supplemental spending bill. For this reason, with heavy hearts, we cannot support this bill in its current form.”
Source ↗, 2024-02-08
“In the short term, the return of the hostages must proceed immediately and aid needs to drastically increase and flow unimpeded into Gaza to address the dire humanitarian crisis.”
Source ↗, 2025-10-09
“U.S. security assistance can no longer serve as a blank check for actions that make Israelis, Palestinians, and the region as a whole less safe.”
Source ↗, 2026-07-20

Research log

The notes behind this card: what we looked at, what we found, and where each item came from.

Every page named below was opened and read on 2026-09-19 unless the entry says otherwise, and his congressional press-release archive was read in full: 44 listing pages, from September 16, 2026 back to January 3, 2023, every item title read and every in-scope item opened. His campaign site was read. Bands: Position (2024-01-26 onward), Reaction window (2023-10-07 to 2024-01-25), Earlier record (before 2023-10-07), Undated. His recorded House votes are shown as badges on this card and are not restated here; this record carries no tracked funding.

U.S. military aid and weapons to the government of Israel

  • [Position, 2025-09-05] His statement on cosponsoring H.R. 3565, the central document on this card. It opens: “Today, after much reflection, I cosponsored H.R. 3565, a bill to stop the transfer of certain offensive weaponry from the United States to Israel. I have taken this action to do my part to pressure Prime Minister Netanyahu to implement a ceasefire in Gaza, allow significantly increased humanitarian aid into Gaza, and to stop the expansion of settlements in the West Bank.” On his own position: “Nevertheless, we are well past the point where a continuation of the war in Gaza serves the best interests of Israelis, Palestinians or Americans and the United States must exert pressure on Netanyahu to change course.” On what he will and will not support: “I will continue to support defensive systems like Iron Dome that protect civilians, as well as targeted actions to remove what remains of Hamas, but I will not support providing the Netanyahu government with additional offensive weaponry until food and medicine are surged into Gaza, Netanyahu presents a workable proposal to end the war that ensures the safety and dignity for both Israelis and Palestinians, independent journalists are permitted to report from Gaza, and rule of law is enforced impartially in the West Bank.” On his own earlier vote: “In April of 2024, I joined 85% of my colleagues in Congress in voting to provide military assistance to Israel. I did so, mindful of the deadly threat that Hamas, Iran, Hezbollah, and other bad actors posed to the civilian population in Israel and across the region.” And on what changed: “But over the past year and a half, the situation has changed. Thankfully, the military strength of Hamas, Iran and Hezbollah have all been significantly degraded. At the same time, the humanitarian crisis in Gaza and lawless killing of Palestinians in the West Bank have reached crisis levels. Netanyahu has presented no plan for achieving peace and appears to believe that the United States will comply with his every whim. It is time to try something different.” The page carries a published date of 2025-09-05.
  • [Position, 2025-05-21 introduced; his cosponsorship recorded 2025-09-08] The bill itself. GovTrack's record of H.R. 3565 gives its official title as “To provide for a limitation on the transfer of defense articles and defense services to Israel”, names Rep. Delia Ramirez of Illinois as its sponsor, records its introduction on May 21, 2025, and lists 81 cosponsors. The cosponsor list carries “Magaziner, Seth [D-RI2, 2023-2026]” against the date September 8, 2025. His own statement is dated September 5, 2025, the Friday before, which is why the two dates differ.
  • [Position, 2026-07-20] The New York Times report of the July 2026 amendment vote and what followed, republished by GV Wire. Under the heading that carries his name the article reports that he said on social media: “U.S. security assistance can no longer serve as a blank check for actions that make Israelis, Palestinians, and the region as a whole less safe.” It adds that he took a similar position the year before when he cosponsored the bill above; the article's own wording there is “He took a similar position last year when he co-sponsored a bill to stop the transfer some offensive weapons to Israel.” The article reports that 103 House Democrats voted for the amendment, that it was defeated, and that he was among eighteen members endorsed by the American Israel Public Affairs Committee who voted for it. The original post of his that the newspaper quotes was not located, so the sentence is carried here as the newspaper reports it.
  • [Position, 2024-02-08] His joint statement with Rep. Gabe Amo on H.R. 7217, the standalone Israel security supplemental. The two wrote: “We strongly support Israel’s right to defend itself against terrorism, including the right to engage in targeted military action to free hostages and eliminate Hamas.” And: “Today’s vote cannot be viewed in isolation. It has been 109 days since President Biden called on Congress to advance funding in support of Israel, humanitarian aid for civilians in Gaza, support for Ukraine, and resources for the Indo-Pacific. And for 109 days, House Republicans have refused to consider the President’s full request. Anything less does not meet the moment, and undermines the bipartisan approach being considered in the Senate.” And: “Humanitarian aid to Gaza is vital to the long-term security of Israelis and Palestinians. Support for Ukraine and the Indo-Pacific is essential to our cause of democracy around the world. These priorities must be included in a supplemental spending bill. For this reason, with heavy hearts, we cannot support this bill in its current form.” The wording is joint and only the collective reading is used. Rep. Amo’s own record is on his own card.
  • [Position, 2026-06-12] The letter 42 lawmakers sent about loan guarantees, led by Rep. Joaquin Castro and Sen. Chris Van Hollen. “Seth Magaziner (D-RI)” appears in the published signer list. The release explains that for over twenty years U.S. law has limited loan guarantees to Israel to within its pre-1967 borders and required the amounts available to be reduced by what the government of Israel spends on settlements in the West Bank, and that the State Department is required to report that figure to Congress. The signers wrote: “The annual reports submitted by the Department of State under this provision have not, for at least a decade, provided the specific calculated figure the statute requires…The substitution of a categorical assertion for a specific figure has deprived Congress of information it is legally entitled to receive and rendered the deduction mechanism opaque for over a decade.” And: “If the administration is considering issuing new sovereign loan guarantees, including to Israel, it is essential that existing provisions in law, including the requirement to report on Israeli expenditures on settlements in the West Bank and the requirement to deduct those amounts from the loan guarantee authorities made available to Israel be followed.” Collective wording throughout, so nothing here is attributed to him alone. The Senate copy of the same release, at https://www.vanhollen.senate.gov/news/press-releases/van-hollen-castro-lead-over-40-lawmakers-in-demanding-transparency-on-us-enforcement-of-laws-regarding-aid-to-israel , refused to open; the House copy above opened and is what is used.
  • [Position, 2025-09-05] Defensive systems. In the same September 2025 statement he says he will continue to support them, naming Iron Dome, and separates them from the offensive weaponry he would withhold. That distinction is recorded here rather than on the card front.
  • Nothing located from him on the memorandum of understanding between the United States and the government of Israel, on Foreign Military Financing by name, or on any specific arms sale.
  • The reaction window is empty on this dimension and on every other. His press-release archive was read page by page across October 7, 2023 to January 25, 2024, and it carries no item on Israel, Gaza, Hamas, Palestinians or antisemitism in that period; nothing else read for this card is dated inside it. His recorded vote of November 2023 is shown as a badge on this card and stands on its own.

U.S. aid to Palestinians

  • [Position, 2024-02-08] The joint statement on H.R. 7217: the absence of humanitarian aid for civilians in Gaza is the first reason the two members give for voting no, and their sentence is quoted in full above.
  • [Position, 2025-10-09] His statement on the first phase of the ceasefire: “After two years of immense suffering, the signing of an initial agreement between Israel and Hamas for the return of the remaining Israeli hostages and a ceasefire in Gaza is welcome and joyful news. I am hopeful that it marks the beginning of a permanent end to this devastating conflict.” And: “Much work remains to ensure this initial agreement turns into a permanent resolution of the conflict and a fair and lasting peace for Israelis and Palestinians. In the short term, the return of the hostages must proceed immediately and aid needs to drastically increase and flow unimpeded into Gaza to address the dire humanitarian crisis.”
  • [Position, 2025-09-05] In the September 2025 statement the first of his four conditions is that food and medicine be surged into Gaza, and he writes that “The Israeli government has also withheld food and medicine from the civilian population in Gaza, causing mass suffering.”
  • [Position, 2025-01-15] His statement on the January 2025 hostage release and ceasefire agreement is three sentences and carries nothing about aid: “Today’s announcement is hopeful news for the hostages and their families who have endured so much.” “Since the October 7th terror attack by Hamas, the Israeli and Palestinian people yearn for peace, as does the entire world.” “I hope that this is the beginning of a process that will lead to a lasting and just peace.”
  • Nothing located from him about the United Nations Relief and Works Agency by name, or about any particular humanitarian appropriation.

Characterization of the conflict

  • [Position, 2025-09-05] The September 2025 statement is where he says most of it. On Hamas and on the right of self-defense: “The current war was initiated by Hamas, a bloodthirsty terrorist organization that continues to hold innocent hostages and must be brought to justice. Israel has a right to defend itself from attacks like the horrific atrocities committed by Hamas on October 7, 2023, and I remain sickened by the rise of antisemitism in our country and globally in recent years, including at times in the anti-war movement.” On the conduct of the war: “The acts of terror committed by Hamas are horrific. But injustice does not justify injustice, and the prolonged suffering of civilians in Gaza must end.” On the West Bank: “At the same time, extremist settlers in the West Bank continue to act with impunity, killing civilians including five Americans, with no legal consequence. Israeli cabinet ministers speak openly of permanently annexing both the West Bank and Gaza and expelling the millions of Palestinians who have called those areas home for generations.” And on his own district: “This is an issue that ignites passion among many Rhode Islanders. The trauma of October 7 continues to weigh on many in the Jewish community, and the images of children suffering in Gaza shock the conscience. My approach will continue to be to use whatever influence I have to end the war and build a future in which Israelis and Palestinians can live in a lasting and secure peace.” He does not use the words genocide or apartheid anywhere in it. The statement also describes reports about particular munitions and about the death toll; those passages are quoted nowhere on this card, because cards here do not reproduce casualty material.
  • [Position, 2024-06-23] The Associated Press report of the Democratic response to Prime Minister Netanyahu’s address to Congress, carried by PBS News, by Farnoush Amiri. He is reported as standing with those who hoped Netanyahu would no longer be prime minister by late July, and as saying of him “bad for Israel, bad for Palestinians, bad for America”; he also said he believed it his job to show up when a head of state addresses Congress. The page would not open to a direct retrieval and was read through the second route, so only the short span above is quoted and the rest is described.
  • [Position, 2025-10-07] His statement marking two years since the October 7 attack: “Today marks two years since the horrific October 7 terrorist attacks on Israel by Hamas, the single deadliest day for Jewish people since the Holocaust and a day we will never forget.” It says nothing about what the United States sends.

Related rhetoric and lobbying

  • [Position, 2026-07-17] Jewish Insider’s report that the American Israel Public Affairs Committee ended fundraising for endorsees who voted for the amendment names “Seth Magaziner (D-RI)” among the eighteen endorsees who voted in favor. The Jewish News Syndicate report of the same day records that archived copies of the organization’s website show donation links removed for fifteen members including “Seth Magaziner (D-R.I.)”. The American Israel Public Affairs Committee is a lobbying organization that works to strengthen the relationship between the United States and the government of Israel and, since 2021, runs political committees that give directly to candidates. No statement of his about the removal was located, and none is attributed to him here.
  • [Position, 2025-09-08] Jewish Insider’s report of the cosponsorship, by way of context for how the step was read at the time. It describes the move as a surprise from a member with “a largely pro-Israel record”, notes that critics describe the bill as an effective arms embargo, and reports that he did not then face a primary challenger. Every quotation in it comes from the statement above, and the statement itself is the source used on this card.
  • [Position, 2025-09-08] Steve Ahlquist’s account of the same step reproduces the statement in full and lists the weapons the bill would cover: BLU-109 bunker-busting bombs, MK80 series bombs, GBU-39 small diameter bomb variants, Joint Direct Attack Munitions, SPICE gliding bomb assemblies, 120mm tank ammunition and 155mm artillery ammunition. Its version of the statement differs from the official one in small ways, so the official page is what is quoted.
  • [Position, 2024-09-03; the event was 2024-08-28] A transcript of a Burrillville Democratic Town Committee meet and greet, published by Steve Ahlquist. Asked by an attendee about organizations “like AIPAC paying $20 million to oust two of your congressional comrades”, he answered that the Citizens United decision should be overturned, that “AIPAC cares about issues having to do with Israel”, and put the group alongside cryptocurrency companies, oil and gas companies and the outside money spent against him in 2022. The reporter states that the transcript was “edited for clarity”, and it is an answer to a question from the floor, so it is recorded here and nothing from it is published as a quotation. It is an argument about campaign money in any case, not a position on what the United States sends.

Safety and antisemitism (context, not an answer to what America sends)

What the campaign site and his own pages say

  • [Undated; read 2026-09-19] His campaign site has four pages: the home page, Meet Seth, a take-action page and a news page. There is no issues page. The home page describes his priorities as Social Security and Medicare, costs for working people, prescription drugs, the Affordable Care Act, gun safety and abortion rights. The news page’s most recent item is dated October 8, 2024. A search of the whole site for israel, gaza, palestin, hamas, antisemit, jewish, aipac, weapon, foreign and middle east returns nothing.
  • [Read 2026-09-19] His congressional press-release archive at https://magaziner.house.gov/media/press-releases runs to 44 listing pages, from September 16, 2026 back to January 3, 2023. Seven items in it touch this subject or its context and all seven are set out above. Two further items are about Iran and are out of scope: his February 2026 statement on military action in Iran and his June 2026 statement on House passage of the Iran war powers resolution.

The race

  • [Read 2026-09-19] The Rhode Island Department of State’s candidate list for Representative in Congress District 2, current as of Saturday, September 19, 2026. Four people declared: Spencer E Dickinson and Seth Michael Magaziner as Democrats, Victor Gilbert Mellor and Stephen T Skoly as Republicans. Two are marked as on the election ballot, Magaziner first and Mellor second. Magaziner is marked as endorsed and as having won his primary. The general election is November 3, 2026.
  • [Read 2026-09-19] Ballotpedia’s page for the race gives the primary as September 9, 2026 and the filing deadline as June 24, 2026, and records that Magaziner advanced from the Democratic primary with 100 percent and 53,802 votes, and that Victor Mellor defeated Stephen Skoly in the Republican primary, 58.6 percent and 8,404 votes to 41.4 percent and 5,936. It lists Spencer Dickinson as withdrawn or disqualified. It also carries a third name in the general election field, Armando Anzoli, described as an independent; his own Ballotpedia page says only that he “declared candidacy for the general election”, and he does not appear on the state’s list above, so this card names two candidates. The vote figures on this record come from the Board of Elections and differ slightly from Ballotpedia’s; both addresses are in the source list below.
  • [Read 2026-09-19] Ballotpedia’s page for him records that he assumed office on January 3, 2023, that he was general treasurer of Rhode Island from 2015 to 2023, and that he holds degrees from Brown University and Yale University. Nothing on the page mentions Israel, Gaza or Palestinians.
  • Victor Mellor’s record is on his own card and is not narrated here.

Places that could not be read, so nothing is claimed from them

  • The social media post the newspaper quotes for the July 2026 sentence. It was not located. His campaign site links four accounts and none was read here; the addresses, exactly as the site gives them, are https://twitter.com/SethMagaziner , https://www.facebook.com/SethMagazinerRI/ , https://www.instagram.com/sethmagazinerri/ and https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCEmc8bXXw8AYVD2txZ5IV9w
  • https://www.vanhollen.senate.gov/news/press-releases/van-hollen-castro-lead-over-40-lawmakers-in-demanding-transparency-on-us-enforcement-of-laws-regarding-aid-to-israel , the Senate copy of the June 2026 letter release, returned 403 on every attempt. The House copy carries the same text and opened.
  • https://www.congress.gov/bill/119th-congress/house-bill/3565/cosponsors returned 403 on every attempt. The cosponsor record was read on GovTrack instead.
  • The full text of the June 2026 letter, which the release links behind a document viewer, was not opened; only the passages the release quotes are used.

Not on the card, and why

  • The quotation our research gave as his, “The current war was initiated by Hamas, a bloodthirsty terrorist organization that continues to hold innocent hostages and must be brought to justice... But injustice does not justify injustice, and the prolonged suffering of civilians in Gaza must end.” Those are two passages from different paragraphs of the September 2025 statement, joined with an ellipsis. Both are quoted separately and in full above.
  • The version our research gave of the opening line, which dropped the second “to” before “stop the expansion of settlements”. The official page is what is quoted.
  • The sentence our research added, that he “emphasized his independence, arguing that foreign policy principles take precedence over political pressure”. The page it is attributed to carries no such statement, and no statement of his about the fundraising portal was found anywhere. Nothing is built on it.
  • His statements about Iran, from February and June 2026. Iran is a different question from what the United States sends to the government of Israel. Both are linked above.
  • The material about antisemitism and about the safety of Jewish communities. It is context and does not answer what America sends. It is set out above with dates.
  • The passages of the September 2025 statement about particular munitions, about the death toll and about the extent of the famine. Cards here do not reproduce casualty material; the statement is linked so a reader can see all of it.
  • The answer he gave at an August 2024 meet and greet about campaign spending by lobbying organizations. It is an answer to a question from the floor in a transcript the reporter says was edited for clarity, and it is about campaign money rather than about what the United States sends.
  • What the Anti-Defamation League asked him for in June 2026. The report carries no answer from him.
  • Victor Mellor’s record, and Rep. Gabe Amo’s. Another candidate’s record belongs on that candidate’s own card.

Sources retrieved for this card (address; opened or could not open; date)

  • https://magaziner.house.gov/media/press-releases/magaziner-statement-co-sponsoring-hr-3565-stop-transfer-certain-offensive (opened; 2026-09-19; published 2025-09-05)
  • https://magaziner.house.gov/media/press-releases/magaziner-amo-issue-joint-statement-hr-7217 (opened; 2026-09-19; published 2024-02-08)
  • https://magaziner.house.gov/media/press-releases/magaziner-statement-israel-and-hamas-reaching-initial-ceasefire-agreement (opened; 2026-09-19; published 2025-10-09)
  • https://magaziner.house.gov/media/press-releases/magaziner-statement-gaza-hostage-release-and-ceasefire-agreement (opened; 2026-09-19; published 2025-01-15)
  • https://magaziner.house.gov/media/press-releases/magaziner-statement-marking-two-years-october-7-attack-israel-hamas (opened; 2026-09-19; published 2025-10-07)
  • https://magaziner.house.gov/media/press-releases/magaziners-statement-antisemitic-mass-shooting-sydney (opened; 2026-09-19; published 2025-12-15)
  • https://magaziner.house.gov/media/press-releases/magaziner-passes-amendment-investigate-racially-and-religiously-motivated (opened; 2026-09-19; published 2025-02-26)
  • https://magaziner.house.gov/media/press-releases/statement-jewish-members-house-representatives-regarding-interview-between (opened; 2026-09-19; published 2024-09-09)
  • https://magaziner.house.gov/media/press-releases/magaziner-statement-military-action-iran (opened; 2026-09-19; published 2026-02-28)
  • https://magaziner.house.gov/media/press-releases/magaziner-statement-house-passage-iran-war-powers-resolution (opened; 2026-09-19; published 2026-06-03)
  • https://magaziner.house.gov/media/press-releases (opened; 2026-09-19; 44 listing pages, September 2026 back to January 2023, all read)
  • https://gvwire.com/2026/07/20/these-aipac-backed-democrats-voted-to-nix-israel-aid-aipac-punished-them/ (opened; 2026-09-19; published 2026-07-20; a New York Times report republished)
  • https://jewishinsider.com/2025/09/seth-magaziner-u-s-weapons-sales-israel-arms-embargo-bill/ (opened; 2026-09-19; published 2025-09-08)
  • https://jewishinsider.com/2026/07/aipac-ends-fundraising-for-endorsees-who-voted-to-end-israel-aid/ (opened; 2026-09-19; published 2026-07-17)
  • https://www.jns.org/news/u-s-news/scoop-aipac-removes-fundraising-links-from-its-site-for-15-house-dems-who-voted-against-aid-to-israel (opened; 2026-09-19; published 2026-07-17)
  • https://steveahlquist.substack.com/p/magaziner-co-sponsoring-bill-to-stop (opened; 2026-09-19; published 2025-09-08)
  • https://steveahlquist.substack.com/p/seth-magaziner-lewis-pryeor-and-paul (opened; 2026-09-19; published 2024-09-03)
  • https://castro.house.gov/media-center/press-releases/castro-van-hollen-lead-40-lawmakers-in-demanding-transparency-on-us-enforcement-of-laws-regarding-aid-to-israel (opened; 2026-09-19; published 2026-06-12)
  • https://www.vanhollen.senate.gov/news/press-releases/van-hollen-castro-lead-over-40-lawmakers-in-demanding-transparency-on-us-enforcement-of-laws-regarding-aid-to-israel (could not open, 403; 2026-09-19)
  • https://www.pbs.org/newshour/politics/many-democrats-plan-to-boycott-netanyahus-address-to-congress-due-to-israels-war-in-gaza (opened on the second route only; 2026-09-19; published 2024-06-23)
  • https://www.jewishrhody.com/stories/one-of-the-most-violent-years-adl-urges-magaziner-on-jewish-safety,168517 (opened; 2026-09-19; published 2026-08-07)
  • https://www.schneiderforcongress.com/news/jewish-members-of-congress-condemn-antisemitic-attacks-in-florida-republican-primary (opened; 2026-09-19; published 2026-08-17)
  • https://www.govtrack.us/congress/bills/119/hr3565 and https://www.govtrack.us/congress/bills/119/hr3565/cosponsors (opened; 2026-09-19)
  • https://www.congress.gov/bill/119th-congress/house-bill/3565/cosponsors (could not open, 403; 2026-09-19)
  • https://sethmagaziner.com/ , https://sethmagaziner.com/meet-seth/ and https://sethmagaziner.com/news/ (opened; 2026-09-19)
  • https://vote.sos.ri.gov/Candidates/CandidateSearchSummary?OfficeType=592&Election=18239 (opened; 2026-09-19)
  • https://ballotpedia.org/Rhode_Island%27s_2nd_Congressional_District_election,_2026 , https://ballotpedia.org/Seth_Magaziner and https://ballotpedia.org/Armando_Anzoli (opened; 2026-09-19)
  • This is a record of what was checked on 2026-09-19, not a claim that no other statement exists.

Also in this race

  1. – Victor Mellor (Republican)

But What Can You Do? tracks where 2026 candidates stand on U.S. weapons and funding for the government of Israel. Every claim on this page goes through at least two verification steps. Open Find Your Candidates for votes, funding and contact details.